Insight,

Developing Robust and Liquid Global Carbon Markets

GLOBAL | EN
Current site :    GLOBAL   |   EN
Australia
China
China Hong Kong SAR
Japan
Singapore
United States
Global

King & Wood Mallesons (Richard Mazzochi, Partner and Claire Potter, Registered Foreign Lawyer (England and Wales)) is delighted to have worked with the Global Financial Markets Association (GFMA) and other leading industry bodies in preparing the GFMA response to the public consultation published by the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO)[1] on recommendations for establishing sound Compliance Carbon Markets and on key considerations for enhancing the resilience and integrity of Voluntary Carbon Markets.

The IOSCO consultation was launched at COP 27 in Sharm el-Sheikh on 9 November 2022 and called on market participants to provide feedback on how to foster fair and functional carbon markets and increase structural resilience to ensure that carbon markets achieve their environmental objectives.

When launching the consultation, the IOSCO Chairman, Jean Paul Servais, commented that: “In recent years, carbon markets have gained significant importance as a mechanism for corporates, and society in general, to facilitate their transition towards net zero. However, they have so far fallen short of their objectives. No market can function without appropriate levels of integrity and, transparency, and liquidity so IOSCO today hopes to lend its international, market expertise to help develop appropriate frameworks for sound and well-functioning carbon markets, focusing on promoting integrity and liquidity and increasing transparency to facilitate price discovery.

The GFMA represents the common interests of the world’s leading financial and capital market participants to provide a collective voice on matters that support global capital markets. The Association for Financial Markets in Europe (AFME) located in London, Brussels, and Frankfurt; the Asia Securities Industry & Financial Markets Association (ASIFMA) in Hong Kong; and the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (SIFMA) in New York and Washington are, respectively, the European, Asian, and North American members of the GFMA.

The GFMA response to the IOSCO report on Compliance Carbon Markets and the IOSCO report on Voluntary Carbon Markets was submitted on 10 February 2023. A copy of the GFMA response to each report can be found here.

The key themes in the GFMA response include those listed below. Critically, both Compliance Carbon Markets and Voluntary Carbon Markets must be underpinned by the same core principles that underpin any sound and robust regulated market: (i) transparency; (ii) integrity; (iii) stability; and (iv) accountability.

Compliance Carbon Markets
Voluntary Carbon Markets
Example uses 2
  • Generate an open and meaningful, cross-industry dialogue with a view to maximising the potential of Compliance Markets.
  • Promote the establishment of a global baseline for the orderly functioning and operation of Compliance Markets.
  • Identify the vulnerabilities associated with upscaling Compliance Markets to mitigate the risk of market abuse and instability.
  • Promote transparent and comprehensive oversight of Compliance Markets, similar to the principles that underpin the integrity and stability of other regulated markets.
  • Strive for certainty as to the legal classification and treatment of carbon allowances.
  • Propose recommendations to relevant authorities (e.g. regulators as well as public policy governmental institutions) to allow for flexibility in the establishment of Compliance Markets and that support meaningful cross-market and cross-border connections in both primary and secondary markets to upscale and accelerate global decarbonisation efforts.
  • Generate an open and meaningful, cross-industry dialogue with a view to maximising the potential of Voluntary Markets.
  • Identify the vulnerabilities relating to Voluntary Markets and collaborate with the private initiatives that seek to address them.
  • Identify the key regulatory considerations relating to Voluntary Markets to guard against market abuse.
  • Promote sound and well-functioning Voluntary Markets that adhere to best practice.
  • Identify and make recommendations to resolve uncertainties relating to the rules and procedures for: (i) trading ‘mitigation outcomes’ (under Article 6.2 of the Paris Agreement); (ii) trading carbon credits (under Article 6.4 of the Paris Agreement); and (iii) developing frameworks for co-operation between countries to reduce emissions through non-market based mechanisms (under Article 6.8 of the Paris Agreement), taking into account ‘corresponding adjustments’ to avoid double counting and double claiming.
  • Strive for certainty as to the legal classification and treatment of carbon credits.
  • Propose recommendations to relevant authorities (e.g. securities and commodities market regulators as well as public policy governmental institutions) to support the integrity and development of primary and secondary Voluntary Markets as a means to upscale and accelerate global decarbonisation efforts.

King & Wood Mallesons is delighted to have held the pen for GFMA in drafting their response to the two IOSCO reports, and thanks GFMA members from across Europe, the United States and Asia for their invaluable input.

King & Wood Mallesons is working with ASIFMA on a study considering Asia’s growing carbon markets and how they can support and upscale global decarbonisation. The ASIFMA paper will build on the significant work already undertaken in connection with the development of safe and effective carbon markets by providing Asia focused guidance on the key issues.

 

Any reference to “Hong Kong” or “Hong Kong SAR” in this article shall be construed as a reference to “Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People’s Republic of China”.

 

Reference

[1]  IOSCO is the leading international policy forum for securities regulators and is recognized as the global standard setter for securities regulation. The organisation's membership regulates more than 95% of the world's securities markets in some 130 jurisdictions.

LATEST THINKING
Insight
Data centres are vital to Australia’s digital future, driving essential services, AI platforms, cloud computing and all of the internet connected devices in each of our homes.

11 June 2025

Insight
Hong Kong is strategically positioned to influence the shift to sustainable finance and drive investment in green technology and infrastructure. One of the chief advantages Hong Kong holds is its potential to act as a super-connector between Mainland China and the global market. Plans made in late 2024 are set to further grow its green debt market and make it a ‘go-to’ for sustainable financing (find more on the Sustainable Finance Action Agenda below).

05 June 2025

Insight
For Japan's energy transition, these agreements are game-changers. In a post-Fukushima context where the country has struggled to balance energy security with decarbonisation goals, corporate PPAs provide a market-based mechanism to finance new renewable capacity outside traditional subsidy schemes. The data centre sector's entrance into this space is particularly noteworthy, as it addresses the dual challenges of powering Japan's digital economy while meeting increasingly stringent corporate environmental commitments.

03 June 2025