26 May 2020

60-second CFIUS: CFIUS seeks termination of a US-China joint venture

In what may be the first action of this type, CFIUS has asked the U.S. party to a China joint venture to terminate its role in the project.

Ekso Bionics Holdings, Inc., a Nasdaq-listed medical devices company, announced a joint venture in January 2019 with Zhejiang Youchuang Venture Capital Investment Co., Ltd. and another partner to develop, sell and support exoskeleton products in Asia. The US party reportedly was to contribute a license to manufacturing technology together with its PRC patent rights; the other parties were to contribute cash.

CFIUS applies to any transaction “by or with any foreign person that could result in foreign control of any U.S. business, including such a transaction carried out through a joint venture.” In the joint venture context, this generally means the parties must take care not to contribute into the joint venture things that, taken together, might constitute a “U.S. business.”

CFIUS regulations suggest a technology license by itself is not a U.S. business. The regulations contain an example in which a license to a foreign party of technology needed to manufacture armored personnel carriers, even when coupled with the sale of the U.S. licensor’s production of APCs, did not constitute the acquisition of a U.S. business. Of course, any technology license would be subject to scrutiny under export regulatory laws, but that is a separate question.

On the other hand, the regulations suggest that “land and equipment … [together with] intellectual property, other proprietary information, and other intangible assets,” when contributed to a joint venture, could constitute a U.S. business. Practitioners generally view the contribution of U.S. personnel to be problematical as well. Where the U.S. assets are not even remotely sufficient to be operated independently as a business, they shouldn’t constitute a “U.S. business.” Many deals do not present such a bright line, however.

After the parties established their joint venture, the U.S. government inquired into the deal, and in December 2019 the parties made a voluntary filing with CFIUS. In its review, CFIUS focused on Ekso’s legacy work for the US government as well as technology transfers and other aspects of the joint venture. At the end of the day, CFIUS was not able to resolve its national security concerns and asked the parties to voluntarily terminate Ekso’s role in the joint venture. The parties have indicated they will work with CFIUS to finalize the terms of an agreement to do so.

This development is sure to cause more waves in an already choppy US-China business environment. But parties should be careful not to generalize from one case, where not all the facts are known.

The 60-second takeaway is this is not positive news, but companies should be careful not to over-generalize from one case.

Belt and Road Hub

We explore the opportunities the Belt and Road Initiative brings for your business, and provide our comprehensive, professional services to help.


Belt and Road

A Guide to Doing Business in China

We explore the key issues being considered by clients looking to unlock investment opportunities in the People’s Republic of China.

Doing Business in China
Share on LinkedIn Share on Facebook Share on Twitter
    You might also be interested in

    This article was written by Edwina Kwan (关凯丽) and Jay Tseng (曾誌輝). In the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, the NSW Supreme Court (Court) vacated the hearing dates for an 8-day trial due to...

    30 June 2020

    This article was written by Patric McGonigal and Ramon Garcia-Gallardo. At a virtual ceremony on 11 June 2020, Singapore's Minister for Home Affairs and Law, K Shanmugam SC and the President of the...

    22 June 2020

    As of May 1, 2020, parties making a voluntary notice filing with CFIUS will have to pay a filing fee. There is no fee for declarations under the mandatory filing regime. The Treasury Department’s...

    19 May 2020

    There is no doubt China deals have been more difficult to clear during the Trump years than they were previously. A database maintained by KWM shows a clearance rate of over 95% during the final...

    08 May 2020

    This site uses cookies to enhance your experience and to help us improve the site. Please see our Privacy Policy for further information. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive these cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time.

    For more information on which cookies we use then please refer to our Cookie Policy.